Concealed Carry Changes Advance In House, Stall In Senate
Florida lawmakers want to cut penalties for people who accidentally show their concealed weapons. The bill is ready for a floor vote in the House. But gun control advocates are worried the plan is a step towards open carry.
Florida is one of just a handful of states to ban the open carry of guns. But Floridians do have the right to concealed carry, if they have a license. And there are real consequences if someone flashes what should be a concealed weapon, whether they have a permit or not.
Cape Coral Republican Representative Dane Eagle wants to change that.
“Current law does not distinguish between someone who may open carry and does not have a concealed weapons permit and someone who may open carry and also has a concealed weapons permit. They treat them equally as a second degree misdemeanor,” Eagle said.
Eagle's bill would give concealed carry permit holders the benefit of the doubt.
“A person who has a concealed weapons permit, rather than receiving that second degree misdemeanor for temporary and open carry, they would receive a $25 civil citation for the first offense, a $500 civil citation for the second offense, and the third offense would be that second degree misdemeanor,” Eagle said.
"Current law does not distinguish between someone who may open carry and does not have a concealed weapons permit and someone who may open carry and also has a concealed weapons permit." - Rep. Dane Eagle (R - Cape Coral)
Eagle’s bill would also change the ban on open carry. Eagle says the law should be more forgiving when some of the state’s 1.8 million permit holders slip up. For reference, Eagle says there are about 150 of these cases per year.
“So these law-abiding otherwise well-intentioned citizens are being arrested and prosecuted for this accident,” Eagle said.
Eagle’s bill would allow for temporary displays, instead of brief ones. And gun control advocates argue the difference between the two is significant. Jamie Ito is with Moms Demand Action for Gun Sense in America.
“This change from brief to temporary was not noted in the bill analysis and it is important to understand and to consider the implications of this change," Ito said. “The safe harbor in this bill is much broader than that under existing law."
She says the change amounts to a backdoor legalization of open carry.
"The safe harbor in this bill is much broader than that under existing law." - Jamie Ito, Gun Control Advocate
“Furthermore, the reductions in penalties found at [Florida Statutes] section 790.053 subparagraph 3 for conduct that is deemed to violate this law to a mere noncriminal $25 fine will incentivize people to violate the law,” Ito said.
Marion Hammer, who represents the NRA, insists the bill is not about open carry.
“This bill does not legalize open carry," Hammer said. "I wish it did.”
But some democratic lawmakers have issues with the language too, like Dania Beach Representative Joe Geller.
"This bill does not legalize open carry. I wish it did." - Marion Hammer, NRA
“I think that we’re opening a door here that is wider than what I take, from what I’ve heard, to be what the sponsor intends,” Geller said. “I think the law as currently written adequately balances the fact that sometimes something happens by accident, with attempting to deter someone from some kind of a brandishment.”
Open carry or not, Rick Soskis is simply worried about the presence of guns in public. He’s a retired nurse and was a longtime gun owner. But after thirty years of working in an emergency room, he told state lawmakers he doesn’t carry anymore.
“Where there are no guns, there are no gun battles. Where there are fewer guns, there are fewer gun battles, gun thefts, gun suicides, gun homicides and accidental gun deaths,” Soskis said.
The measure passed its last House committee on a largely party line vote. It’s now ready for the floor. But the plan is getting virtually no traction in the Senate. Lawmakers there have already blocked a similar bill.