© 2026 WFSU Public Media
WFSU News · Tallahassee · Panama City · Thomasville
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Tallahassee’s new commission fires city manager and will revisit ICE agreement

Karen Jumonville, one of the three finalists for Tallahassee City Manager, talks during the finalist meet-and-greet event on Sept. 1, 2026.
Tristan Wood
/
WFSU Public Media
Former Tallahassee City manager Karen Jumonville talks to a community member during a meet-and-greet event during the last city manager selection process on Sept. 1, 2026.

Tallahassee’s new city commission voted 3–2 Wednesday to fire City Manager Karen Jumonville, fulfilling a campaign theme of the new city hall majority.

The decision came despite a provision in her contract requiring four votes for termination.

Mayor Jeremy Matlow made the motion to fire Jumonville. He says the hiring process under the previous commission undermined his trust in her leadership. He doesn’t believe the four-vote provision is legally binding because the city charter says the manager serves at the will of the commission.

“We can't move forward as a city with a city manager that doesn't have a relationship with the mayor that's based on a trust and mutual respect, and we just don't have that right now,” he said.

Commissioners Curtis Richardson and Dianne Williams-Cox opposed the move. Richardson says Jumonville deserves a chance after 27 years working for the city.

“I cannot see myself voting to terminate or cancel the city manager's contract. I know it will cost the city, but that wasn't our choice to make,” he said.

Newly elected Commissioner PJ Perez says the previous commission created the situation by appointing Jumonville just weeks before the election. He also takes issue with the four-vote provision.

“I think this was the outgoing regime's attempt to maintain a preferred administrator from an impending electoral shift,” he said.

The commission voted to appoint Deputy City Attorney Lou Norvell as interim city manager, effective immediately. Norvell gave a few hundred dollars to Matlow and Perez’s campaigns this election cycle. Both campaigned on leadership changes at City Hall.

Norvell told commissioners he would take on the additional responsibilities without a raise or contract.

“I want the best for the City of Tallahassee. The honest truth: if I needed to do it for free, I'd do it for free. I mean, there's a limitation on how long I could do that, but I'd do it. And I think that we need change, and I think that we need better government,” he said.

Jumonville has retained an attorney. The city attorney says the decision could expose Tallahassee to a breach-of-contract lawsuit.

During the meeting, commissioners also voted to revisit whether to end the Tallahassee Police Department’s 287(g) agreement with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement.

Florida law requires sheriffs to enter into those agreements. The requirement doesn’t extend to city police departments. Still, Republican Attorney General James Uthmeier has threatened other cities that considered ending their agreements. Tallahassee previously considered ending its agreement but left it in place.

Matlow says he wants to end it.

“My view is, when you look at the state law, it's pretty clear we didn't have a mandate. The state admitted that in court that they didn't have a mandate, and now they have placed Amendment Three on us to reduce our budgets, even further straining our budget to have an unfunded mandate to provide federal civil immigration services. I don't think it's tenable,” he said.

The commission also voted to consider an in-depth agenda item unpacking an MOU agreement between the city and Leon County commission resolving their fight regarding the fire service fee. Matlow and County Commissioner Christian Caban negotiated the general terms, and the county commission recently voted to continue with the MOU to bring it toward a final agreement.

The Tallahassee Commission will have that item in January.

Tristan Wood is a senior producer and host with WFSU Public Media. A South Florida native and University of Florida graduate, he focuses on state government in the Sunshine State and local panhandle political happenings.