Ethiopia Stifles Dissent, While Giving Impression Of Tolerance, Critics Say

Jun 8, 2016
Originally published on June 15, 2016 7:41 am

The Oromo Federalist Congress, an opposition party in Ethiopia, represents the largest ethnic group in the country, the Oromo.

Yet its office in the capital Addis Ababa is virtually deserted, with chairs stacked up on tables. A chessboard with bottle caps as pieces is one of the few signs of human habitation. In a side office, the party's chairman, Merera Gudina, explains why the place is so empty: Almost everyone has gone to prison.

The deputy chairman? Prison. The party secretary general? House arrest. The assistant secretary general? In prison. Six members of the party's youth league? All in prison.

Critics of the Ethiopian government regularly land in prison. So why isn't Merera Gudina, the chairman of the party and an outspoken critic of the regime, also behind bars?

The reason, he says, is what he calls "the game of the 21st century." Less-than-democratic regimes are getting more sophisticated, and instead of completely crushing dissent, they seek to create the appearance of tolerance or even a multiparty democracy, explains Merera. (Ethiopians go by their first names).

In the case of Ethiopia, a strategy was laid out by the late former prime minister, Meles Zenawi, after the 2005 election, in which opposition parties won 32 percent of parliament and appeared poised to challenge the government.

"Wait for the opposition to grow legs," Meles said in a meeting with top party officials. "And then cut them off."

Merera says he is the current example of that strategy. He describes himself as a "floating head," while the legs of his party — all his deputies, his candidates, his organizers — are either imprisoned or threatened.

Criticism On Human Rights

Human rights groups are extremely critical of Ethiopia, but it is a member of the international community in good standing.

President Obama paid a visit in July of last year, the first ever by a sitting U.S. president, and held a press conference with Ethiopia's Prime Minister Hailemariam Desalegn.

"We are very mindful of Ethiopia's history, the hardships that this country has gone through," Obama said. "It has been relatively recently in which the Constitution that was formed, and elections put forward a democratically elected government."

A number of human rights groups criticized Obama, saying he should have pressed much harder.

Shortly before Obama's visit, Ethiopia released several noted opposition journalists and politicians. The deputy chairman of the Oromo Federalist Congress, Bekele Gerba, was among those freed, and he promptly flew to Washington to sound an alarm bell.

"Every one of us is in a very high risk," he told NPR's Michele Kelemen. "Because anybody who criticizes the government is always a suspect."

Bekele said his wife, a high school teacher, was also forced out of her job because of his politics. Bekele declined to use this trip to the U.S. to stay and apply for asylum. Instead, he said, he was determined to go back to Ethiopia, no matter what would happen.

Opposition Figure Re-Arrested

Soon after his return, Bekele was arrested again, and remains in prison today. Bekele is considered a moderate and he counsels nonviolence. He used his free time in prison to translate the writings of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.

Merera, the party leader, says that targeting Bekele has a boomerang effect.

"When you are suppressing the moderate voice, then what you get is the radical voice," he warns.

The arrest of moderates inside the country may be amplifying more radical rhetoric in the diaspora, such as rhetoric about "government overthrow" that Ethiopian officials are quick to highlight.

Genenew Assefa, a government spokesman, points out that Ethiopian opposition "tends to be extremist," but also takes his own Justice Ministry to task for arresting so many opposition members.

"And then we put them in jail, and then it's a vicious circle," he says with a sigh. "And this is how it works. I personally, you know, would like to deal with this differently."

He says that he would like Ethiopia to counter criticism with politics, not with police.

But Ethiopian politics appears to be moving away from democratic freedoms, not toward them. In last year's election, the ruling party won 100 percent of the seats in parliament. Even the "floating heads" no longer have a token parliamentary seat.

Merera says that the Ethiopian strategy isn't working.

"You can't arrest everybody," he says. He says that what is brewing is "an intifada (uprising), an Ethiopian intifada — even now, they don't need leadership."

Last November, ethnically Oromo regions of the country erupted in popular protests. Activists say 350 people have been killed, and thousands more arrested. There's a growing fear that Ethiopia's "cut off the legs" strategy is splitting the country.

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

ROBERT SIEGEL, HOST:

In stories from countries ruled by authoritarian regimes, it's common to hear that leaders of the opposition have been put in jail. But in Ethiopia, the regime has stood that well worn strategy on its head. NPR's Gregory Warner reports.

GREGORY WARNER, BYLINE: The late former prime minister of Ethiopia, Meles Zenawi, has some interesting advice for his followers in 2005. This was just after an election where opposition parties had won 32 percent of parliament. This was a first in Ethiopian history. And Meles counseled patience. He said, we wait for the opposition to grow legs, and then we cut them off. Merera Gudina explains the idea of with this phase in Amharic.

MERERA GUDINA: Ayarlai Mansafaf.

WARNER: Ayarlai Mansafaf, which means...

GUDINA: It means you simply make the leadership float in the air.

WARNER: Now, Merera should know. He is one of those floating heads. He's the chairman of the Oromo Federalist Congress, an opposition party that represents Ethiopia's largest ethnic group, the Oromo. And as the party leader, Merera is free to criticize the Ethiopian government publicly and not get arrested. Those just under him - the legs of the party, so to say - almost all in prison.

GUDINA: For example, my closest friend is in prison.

WARNER: He goes through the roll call. His deputy chairman - in prison, the party secretary general - on house arrest, the assistant secretary general - also in prison.

GUDINA: Six leaders of the Youth League, the chairman, the vice chairman, head of the organization, head of the public relations. These people are in prison.

WARNER: Do you ever give people a warning speech? Like, do you tell them, look; if you join me, there could be risks.

GUDINA: No, we know that. We - they know it. We know it. That's what's a game of the 21st century.

WARNER: If the game of the 21st century dictatorship is to stifle dissent while observing the ceremony of democracy, the game of the 21st century Ethiopian activists may be to speak out even knowing you're walking into a spider web.

Last year at our NPR studio in Washington, we got a visit from Bekele Gerba. He's the deputy chairman of this opposition party.

BERKELE GERBA: Every one of us is in a very high risk because anybody who criticizes the government is always a suspect.

WARNER: If he sounds tired, he was. He'd just been released from Ethiopian prison. He said his wife, a high school teacher, was also forced out of her job because of his politics.

GERBA: I'm not sure what will happen to me, but I'm determined to go back again.

WARNER: And soon after his return to Ethiopia, he was tossed in prison again, where he is today. And Berkele is a moderate. He counsels nonviolence. He used downtime in prison to translate the writings of Martin Luther King. And Merera says that targeting somebody like that has a boomerang effect.

GUDINA: The problem is, when you are suppressing the moderate voice, then what you get is the radical voice.

WARNER: The arrest of moderates inside Ethiopia maybe amplifying more radical rhetoric in the diaspora, rhetoric about government overthrow that Ethiopian officials are quick to highlight.

GENENEW ASSEFA: It has been a disservice for Ethiopia that the opposition tends to be extremist.

WARNER: Government spokesman Genenew Assefa also criticized his own justice ministry for arresting, he said, too many opposition members.

ASSEFA: And then we put them to jail, and then it's a vicious circle. And this is how it works. Although I personally, you know, would like to deal with this differently.

WARNER: He'd deal with opposition criticism through politics, not through the police. But Ethiopian politics appears to be moving away from democratic freedoms, not towards them. Unlike 2005, when opposition parliamentarians won all those seats, in last year's election, the ruling party won 100 percent - all the seats of Parliament. Even the floating heads no longer have a token place.

Six months later, some ethnically Oromo regions reasons of the country erupted in popular protests. Activists say 350 people have been killed and thousands more arrested. There's a real fear that Ethiopia's cut-off-the-leg strategy is splitting the country. Gregory Warner, NPR News, Addis Ababa. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.